Summer vs Scarlet Tanager is a fun and colorful birdwatching debate. Both birds are bright, bold, and full of charm. I’ve watched them for years and still find new things to love. They may look alike at first, but their songs, habits, and colors tell a different story. In this guide, I’ll share how these two tanagers stand apart in the best ways.
Table of Contents
9 Main Differences
I’ve been lucky to watch both the Summer and Scarlet Tanager in their natural spaces. At first, I confused them—those bold reds and forest calls can trick even seasoned birders. But once you slow down and look closely, their differences become crystal clear.
1. Size and Weight
The Summer Tanager is about 6.7 in (17 cm) long, weighing up to 1.19 oz (33.6 g). The Scarlet Tanager ranges from 6.3–7.5 in (16–19 cm), often a bit heavier, up to 1.34 oz (38 g).
2. Range and Distribution
Summer Tanagers breed in the southern U.S. and migrate to Central America. Scarlet Tanagers stick to the eastern U.S. and winter in South America.
3. Habitat Preference
Scarlets love deep oak forests. Summers go for pine-oak woodlands or riparian zones. I’ve seen both on the same trail—but in very different corners.
4. Flight and Escape Behavior
Scarlets dart fast between branches. Summers glide more, often flying out to catch bugs mid-air. Each has a style that fits its surroundings.
5. Feeding Habits
Both eat insects and fruit. But Summer Tanagers specialize in wasps and bees. I once saw one raking a wasp before swallowing—it was impressive.
6. Breeding and Nesting
Both nest high in trees. Scarlets prefer dense forest interiors. Summers are more flexible, nesting in open woodlands too.
7. Hunting Techniques
Summer Tanagers often sally out to catch flying insects. Scarlet Tanagers may hunt closer to the forest floor, even flipping leaves for bugs.
8. Personality and Interaction
Scarlets are shyer, more reserved. Summers feel bolder—they’ll sing right above your head and barely flinch. I love their confidence.
9. Conservation and Status
Both species are listed as “Least Concern,” but Scarlet Tanagers are more affected by habitat loss. Forest fragmentation is a real threat.
Summer Tanager
If you’ve ever heard a soft, whistling song coming from the treetops in summer, chances are, it might’ve been a Summer Tanager. Over the past couple of years, I’ve spent time observing this bird, and I’m excited to share everything I’ve learned.
What I Like
I’ve grown quite fond of the Summer Tanager for several reasons. Here’s why it stands out and how it brings joy to my birdwatching days:
- Its bright color makes it easy to spot. The deep red of the male is a feast for the eyes, especially against green leaves.
- Its voice is soothing. I often sit outside just to hear its soft, robin-like song. It’s like nature’s own calming playlist.
- They keep bugs in check. These birds love bees and wasps—so they’re like a flying pest control squad.
- They’re shy but charming. You feel rewarded when you finally spot one. It’s like meeting a secret forest friend.
- Their gentle habits make them peaceful to watch. Unlike louder birds, they move with calm energy. It’s therapeutic.
Their Role in Nature and Unique Personalities
Over time, I’ve noticed how the Summer Tanager quietly supports the ecosystem.
- They help control insect populations, especially wasps and bees. I’ve seen one rake a bee against a branch before eating it—it’s both smart and fearless!
- They migrate with the seasons, playing a role in seed dispersal by eating fruit across regions.
- Each bird has its own rhythm—some sing more, some stay hidden, but all carry a graceful presence.
- Even though they’re a bit hard to find, when they do show up, they light up the place with color and sound.
My Personal Experience
I have been seeing this bird for over 2 years now, mostly during the warmer months. The more I learn about it, the more I admire how quiet yet impactful it is in the wild.
Appearance
At first glance, the male Summer Tanager is impossible to forget.
- The males are bright rose red all over. There’s no other bird quite like it in the canopy.
- Females are a lovely yellow-olive—they blend in more, but when the light hits them right, they glow.
- They don’t have fancy patterns, but the color alone makes them feel like forest royalty.
Size
I was surprised by how modest their size is.
- They’re about 17 cm long, just a bit larger than a sparrow.
- Their wingspan is around 28–30 cm, which helps them glide smoothly through the trees.
- Small but mighty—their presence feels larger than life when they sing.
Behavior & Diet
Observing their habits taught me a lot about patience and precision.
- They love hunting insects mid-air, then returning to the same perch.
- I’ve seen one catch a wasp and scrape the stinger off before eating—pretty clever!
- They also eat fruit, especially during migration. I’ve even spotted one near fruiting trees in gardens.
Habitat & Range
Where you find them says a lot about their character.
- In my area, they prefer tall trees in quiet, wooded spaces.
- They range from the southern U.S. to parts of Central and South America.
- In summer, I usually find them in open forests or along shady trails.
Nesting & Reproduction
I once spotted a nest high on a horizontal branch—neat and tidy.
- They build cup-shaped nests out of grasses and spider silk.
- Nests can be anywhere from 4 to 45 feet high.
- They typically raise one brood per season, and the female does most of the nesting work.
Symbolism
The Summer Tanager reminds me of stillness and subtle joy.
- Its red color often symbolizes energy and passion, yet the bird is gentle.
- It teaches that being bold doesn’t mean being loud—sometimes beauty lies in quiet moments.
Physical Features
They’re built for both beauty and function.
- Their pointed bills are ideal for snatching insects mid-air.
- Though not as thick as other cardinals, the bill still gets the job done.
- Their body is slim, their flight smooth, and they’re designed for warm forest life.
Types of Summer Tanager
Over time, I learned there are two main types based on where they live.
- P. r. rubra: Found in the eastern U.S., winters in Central America and northern South America.
- P. r. cooperi: Found in the southwest U.S., winters in southern Mexico.
- I’ve mostly seen the eastern kind—but someday I hope to spot the other!
Importance of Summer Tanager
These birds are quiet heroes of the forest.
- They balance insect populations, especially stinging pests.
- Their fruit-eating helps spread seeds, supporting forest growth.
- Watching them also reminds us to slow down and listen—a gift in today’s busy world.
Fun Facts About Summer Tanager
Here are a few things that made me smile.
- They’re known to eat over 50 types of insects!
- They don’t sing while migrating, which is how I know when they’ve arrived.
- One was once seen trying to eat a green lizard—bold, right?
- Planting fruit trees like mulberry or dogwood might attract them to your yard.
- Despite being bright red, they’re often hard to spot—like a hidden ruby in the woods.
Scarlet Tanager
There’s something about the Scarlet Tanager that feels almost magical. Over the past few years, I’ve had the joy of watching them during spring and summer. Their color, call, and quiet charm keep drawing me back.
What I Like
When I first spotted a Scarlet Tanager, I was speechless. Here’s why I keep looking out for them every year:
- That red color is unforgettable. It’s like seeing a spark of fire up in the trees—totally breathtaking.
- They’re calm and graceful. Their stillness has a grounding effect. Watching them feels peaceful.
- Their song feels familiar. Like a husky version of a robin, it always stops me in my tracks.
- They stay high in the trees. I love the challenge of spotting them—it’s like a treasure hunt.
- They’re rare but rewarding. When you do see one, it feels like nature handed you a secret.
Their Role in Nature and Unique Personalities
The more I learn about the Scarlet Tanager, the more I respect its quiet role in the wild.
- They’re top-notch bug hunters, especially in the treetops. I’ve seen them snatch wasps, beetles, and even spiders!
- They clean up forest pests while looking good doing it—who says beauty and purpose can’t mix?
- Each one seems a little different. Some sing often, some stay silent—but they always look alert and wise.
- They avoid noise and chaos, sticking to deep woods. It makes seeing them feel even more special.
My Personal Experience
I have been seeing this bird for over 2 years now—mostly during my morning walks through old oak woods. Every time I spot one, I feel like I’ve unlocked a hidden part of the forest.
Appearance
The Scarlet Tanager looks like it flew straight out of a painting.
- Males are fiery red with jet-black wings. You can’t mistake them for anything else.
- Females wear yellowish-green. They’re quieter in color but have a gentle charm.
- Their plumage shifts in fall, with males turning olive like females—a surprise every season.
Size
Though small, the Scarlet Tanager leaves a lasting impression.
- They’re about 6.5 to 7.5 inches long—not too big, not too small.
- Their wingspan is just under a foot, but they move so gracefully through the canopy.
- Despite their size, their song and color make them stand out far more than expected.
Behavior & Diet
I’ve spent quiet mornings watching their hunting skills.
- They hunt from a perch, darting out to catch insects mid-air—a move called “sallying.”
- I’ve seen them eat wasps, moths, cicadas—even snails and spiders.
- They switch to fruit when bugs are scarce, and I’ve found them near mulberry trees in late summer.
Habitat & Range
They love deep, old woods—just like me.
- I usually find them in deciduous forests with big trees, especially oaks.
- They migrate from South America, arriving here around May and leaving by October.
- They avoid cities but can be found in quiet parks or big yards with tall trees.
Nesting & Reproduction
Once, I was lucky enough to find a nest tucked away in a high branch.
- They build small cup nests on horizontal limbs, often hidden in leaves.
- Four eggs is typical, light blue with tiny marks.
- Only one brood per year, and if disturbed, they rarely try again—something that made me realize how sensitive they are.
Symbolism
To me, the Scarlet Tanager stands for wonder and surprise.
- Its bold color reminds me to be confident, even when staying quiet.
- It feels like a symbol of hidden beauty—present only to those who take time to look.
- It’s a reminder that stillness can be powerful, and sometimes the brightest things are found in the shadows.
Physical Features
Beyond the color, their features are built for quiet mastery.
- Their sturdy bill handles both insects and fruit—no need for flash, just function.
- Soft, sleek feathers help them blend into summer leaves when they want to disappear.
- Their movements are smooth, always aware but never rushed.
Types of Scarlet Tanager
There’s just one main type, but the seasonal look makes it feel like two different birds.
- In breeding season, males wear that deep red coat with black wings.
- In fall and winter, even males turn olive-green, like the females.
- This change always surprises new birders—like nature playing dress-up.
Importance of Scarlet Tanager
This bird plays a bigger role than most people think.
- They help control insect numbers—a natural, eco-friendly pest manager!
- Their presence tells you the forest is healthy, since they only stay where the habitat is right.
- They inspire people to protect nature—that’s a huge impact, even for a tiny bird.
Fun Facts About Scarlet Tanager
These little facts always make me smile when I think about them:
- They rake stingers off wasps before eating them—smart and brave!
- They travel over 4,000 miles during migration.
- Despite their bright color, they’re hard to spot unless you’re really looking.
- They don’t raise a second brood, which makes their first nest even more important.
- Once, I spotted one in the rain—even soaked, it looked stunning.
Summer vs Scarlet Tanager: Detailed Comparison
I’ve been seeing both the Summer Tanager and the Scarlet Tanager for a few years now. Each has its own charm, and I’ve spent many hours watching, listening, and learning about their habits up close.
Appearance: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Both birds are striking, but in very different ways. Their colors are bold and memorable, making them stand out in the forest.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Male Plumage | Solid rose red | Bright red with black wings & tail |
| Female Plumage | Yellow-olive with soft wings | Yellow-olive overall with slightly darker wings |
| Fall Plumage (Males) | Keeps reddish tone | Turns olive like the female |
| Visual Impact | Subtle, smooth beauty | Sharp contrast and vivid appearance |
Size: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Both birds are similar in size, but the Scarlet Tanager can appear a bit stockier.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Length | About 17 cm (6.7 in) | 16–19 cm (6.3–7.5 in) |
| Weight | 25.8–33.6 g (avg. 30 g) | 23.5–38 g (avg. 25–35 g) |
| Wingspan | 28–30 cm | 25–30 cm |
Behavior & Diet: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Their diets overlap, but their feeding styles and preferences vary in subtle but interesting ways.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Diet Type | Mostly insects, especially bees/wasps; some fruit | Insects and fruit; includes spiders, snails, wasps |
| Feeding Style | Slow movements, forages from high perches | “Sallying” from branches; also hunts on forest floor |
| Song | Smooth and robin-like | Rougher, hoarse version of robin’s song |
| Personality | Calm and secretive | Cautious but vocal in short bursts |
Habitat & Range: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Where you find them depends on the season and the region. I’ve seen both in woodlands, but under different conditions.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Breeding Range | Southern and eastern U.S., up to Iowa and New Jersey | Eastern North America, especially oak forests |
| Winter Range | Mexico to northern South America | Northwestern South America |
| Habitat | Riparian woodlands, open forests | Deep deciduous woods, especially oak-rich areas |
Nesting & Reproduction: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Their nesting habits show how much environment shapes behavior. I’ve spotted nests from both, but only from afar.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Nest Location | 4–45 feet up on horizontal branches | Similar height, hidden in dense canopy |
| Eggs per Clutch | Usually 3–5 | Typically 4 (range 3–5) |
| Broods per Season | One | One |
| Nest Materials | Grass, spider silk | Fine twigs, grass, rootlets |
Symbolism: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Each bird evokes different feelings for me. Their symbolism reflects both their look and their spirit.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Symbolism | Calm joy, quiet strength | Hidden passion, fiery spirit |
| What It Represents | Beauty in stillness, gentle confidence | Bold color in quiet places, inner fire |
Hunting: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Both are skilled insect hunters, but I’ve seen some standout behaviors in each.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Prey Preference | Bees, wasps, flies, fruit | Wasps, ants, spiders, moths, snails, fruit |
| Hunting Method | Catch and scrape stingers off prey | Rake stingers off branch, also hunts from ground |
| Hunting Style | Patient and perch-focused | Active and mobile, more variety in style |
Defense Mechanisms: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
Both birds rely more on staying hidden than fighting back. But they handle threats differently.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Defense Strategy | Stealth, nesting high | Avoids fragmented habitats, prefers deep forest |
| Reaction to Disturbance | May abandon nest | Often avoids nesting again if disturbed |
| Nesting Threats | Unknown specifics, likely similar predators | High risk from cowbirds, jays, crows, raccoons |
Interaction with Humans: Summer vs Scarlet Tanager
From my experience, these birds are shy but not unreachable. Here’s how they relate to people.
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Seen in Yards? | Occasionally, near fruit trees or feeders | Rarely, prefers deep woods or large parks |
| Reaction to People | Shy but tolerant if undisturbed | Very cautious, disappears quickly when spooked |
| Attracting Them | Planting fruit trees like dogwood or mulberry | Preserve large tree cover; avoid habitat split |
Summer vs Scarlet Tanager Sound
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Song Description | Smooth, robin-like; calm and repetitive | Hoarser, rougher than robin’s song; slightly more variable |
| Common Call Note | Sharp “pi-tuk” or “pik-i-tuk-i-tuk” | Raspy “chip-burr” or “chip-churr” |
| Confusion Factor | Often mistaken for robins due to tone | Sounds like robin with a cold—easy to tell apart once heard |
| Best Heard In | Early mornings in open woodlands | Dense deciduous forests in spring |
Summer vs Scarlet Tanager Size
| Feature | Summer Tanager | Scarlet Tanager |
| Length | 6.7 in (17 cm) | 6.3–7.5 in (16–19 cm) |
| Weight | 0.99–1.19 oz (25.8–33.6 g) | 0.83–1.34 oz (23.5–38 g) |
| Wingspan | 11–12 in (28–30 cm) | 9.8–11.8 in (25–30 cm) |
| Build | Slimmer body, delicate profile | Slightly bulkier with a stocky look |
Summer Tanager Female
| Feature | Summer Tanager Female |
| Coloration | Olive-yellow on back, orange-yellow underparts |
| Size | Length: 6.7 in (17 cm); Weight: ~1 oz (30 g) |
| Plumage Changes | Subtle; remains fairly consistent year-round |
| Behavior | Quiet, reserved, often foraging alone in the canopy |
| Visibility | Harder to spot than males due to muted tones |
Scarlet Tanager Male vs Female
| Feature | Male Scarlet Tanager | Female Scarlet Tanager |
| Breeding Plumage | Bright red body with jet-black wings/tail | Yellow-olive body and wings |
| Winter Plumage | Turns olive-green like the female | Stays similar year-round |
| Size | Same as female: Length: 6.3–7.5 in (16–19 cm) | Length: 6.3–7.5 in (16–19 cm) |
| Behavior | More vocal, especially during breeding season | Quieter, more secretive in movement |
Scarlet Tanager Range
| Feature | Scarlet Tanager |
| Breeding Range | Eastern U.S. and southern Canada (esp. oak-rich forests) |
| Wintering Range | Northwestern South America (Colombia, Ecuador, Peru) |
| Migration Pattern | North in May, south by early October |
| Typical Habitats | Forest interiors, large parks, mature deciduous woodlands |
| Range Extremes | Rare vagrant to western Europe |
Scarlet Tanager Lifespan
| Feature | Scarlet Tanager Lifespan |
| Average Lifespan | Around 5 years in the wild |
| Maximum Recorded | Up to 11 years (based on banding data) |
| Juvenile Risks | High mortality in first year due to predators |
| Main Threats | Predation, collisions, brood parasitism, weather |
| Survival Boosts | Deep forest habitats improve long-term survival |
What is the main difference between the Summer vs Scarlet Tanager?
The Summer Tanager is all red, while the Scarlet Tanager has a red body with black wings. Learn more about their stunning looks and songs.
Which bird sings better: Summer or Scarlet Tanager?
The Summer Tanager sounds smooth and mellow, while the Scarlet Tanager has a rougher, sharper song. Learn more about how each bird uses its voice.
Where can I see a Summer vs Scarlet Tanager in the wild?
You’ll find Summer Tanagers in the South and West, and Scarlet Tanagers in eastern forests. Learn more about their seasonal ranges and habitat tips.
Are Summer vs Scarlet Tanagers easy to tell apart?
Yes—color, sound, and habitat help you spot the difference. Learn how to ID both birds even at a glance.
Which bird is more common: Summer or Scarlet Tanager?
Scarlet Tanagers are more widespread in the East, while Summer Tanagers are common in the South. Learn more about when and where to find each one.
Conclusion
In the Summer vs Scarlet Tanager debate, both birds shine in their own way. The Summer Tanager brings calm beauty, while the Scarlet Tanager adds bold contrast. Each one offers something special. Whether you spot them in the trees or hear their songs, they leave a lasting mark. I’ve loved getting to know both—and I hope you will too.
Also Read: Vermilion Flycatcher vs Scarlet Tanager : 9 Main Difference
I still remember the day that sparked my love for birds. I was just a kid, sitting in my backyard, when a tiny bird landed near me. It moved so fast, its feathers flashing in the sunlight, and then it sang—soft, clear, and almost magical. In that moment, birds became more than just creatures in the sky. They became a mystery I wanted to solve.
That curiosity never faded. It led me to study Biology at the University of Scranton, where I dove deep into the science of birds—their behavior, their calls, and the incredible ways they survive. Today, that same passion drives me, and through Earth of Birds, I get to share it with you.
Discover more from Earth of Birds
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.